42nd Street Bagel Cafe

Nestled in the heart of Claremont, 42nd Street Bagel Cafe delivers a vibrant and flavorful breakfast experience that keeps locals and visitors coming back for more. Specializing in bagels and breakfast fare, this delightful cafe masterfully blends New York bagel tradition with creative culinary twists, giving patrons an array of enticing options that satisfy both classic cravings and adventurous palates.

The menu reads like a love letter to bagel aficionados and breakfast lovers alike. From the iconic Bagel and Lox, featuring delicate smoked salmon layered perfectly atop cream cheese, to inventive star dishes such as the Pizza Bagel and the zesty Jalapeño Bagel—each bite bursts with freshness and expertly balanced flavors. The savory Bagel Dog with Provolone Cheese and the hearty Vegetarian Garden Patty Melt on a Jalapeño Cheese Bagel showcase the cafe's bold approach to reinventing bagel sandwiches, ensuring every craving is met with satisfaction.

Beyond bagels, 42nd Street Bagel Cafe surprises with distinct offerings like the vibrant Paella Mixta and the intriguing Squid in Black Ink. For those looking for lighter fare, their selection of Garden Fresh Salads—from the crisp Chinese Chicken Salad to the classic Caesar—provides a refreshing counterpoint. And don’t miss the house specialty of Flan, a silky, sweet finish to any meal, rounding out the experience with comforting elegance.

The atmosphere here is warm and inviting. Customers consistently praise the friendly, attentive service—especially noting staff members like Amani, whose genuine warmth and helpfulness make deciding from the tempting menu a pleasure rather than a challenge. The cafe offers both a cozy indoor setting and a pleasant patio space, perfect for soaking in the casual charm of a sunny Claremont morning while savoring a fresh cup of excellent coffee alongside your meal. Whether grabbing a quick takeout or settling in for a relaxed breakfast, the balance of laid-back vibe and quality fare creates a memorable stop.

Reviewers frequently express their delight with the authenticity and quality of the bagels here. One visitor raves about the everything bagel club with added red onions, calling it “fresh” and “aesthetically pleasing,” while another confesses that after sampling true New York bagels, 42nd Street remains a favorite local gem. The jalapeño cheese bagel with lox earns high praise for its perfect blend of smoky, spicy, and creamy flavors, with multiple customers eager to return and indulge again.

In essence, 42nd Street Bagel Cafe captures the heart and soul of bagel craftmanship with a lively menu that caters to all tastes, flawless hospitality, and an ambiance that feels like a neighborhood treasure. Whether you're craving the comforting classics or want to explore unique, bold flavors, this spot promises a fulfilling and appetizing start to your day in Claremont.